Geyto Research · Mariano D'Angelo · Evidence review · · 2 min read
Why training does not always reach the job
Training transfer depends on who learns, how it is taught and the work environment, the hardest of the three to control. What the evidence says.
In brief: training can be well designed and still not change the work. Research on transfer of learning shows that the work environment weighs heavily on whether what is learned gets applied: if it does not allow and sustain it, transfer drops. That is why training matters, but it is not enough: capacity is also built where the work happens.
The Baldwin and Ford model
In 1988, Timothy Baldwin and Kevin Ford reviewed the research on training transfer: the degree to which what is learned is used on the job and maintained. They organized the factors into three groups:
- The learner: their prior experience, their motivation and their confidence.
- The training design: how closely it resembles the real situation, how much practice it includes, what examples it uses.
- The work environment: support from the supervisor and from peers, and the real opportunity to apply what was learned.
The third group is the one a training team controls least, and it weighs heavily on whether what was learned can be used. A person can leave a course knowing how to use a system and return to a job where there is no time to do things differently, where the supervisor still asks for the usual report or where the old spreadsheet is faster.
Learning by taking part
Jean Lave and Etienne Wenger proposed an idea that changed how learning at work is understood. In their situated learning approach, people learn by taking part in a real practice, alongside those who have already mastered it, starting with peripheral tasks and moving towards the central ones.
For an implementation, this means the training room is only one part. The other part happens on the job, with real cases, with someone nearby to ask and with room to make mistakes without serious consequences.
What cannot be written down
Michael Polanyi summed up tacit knowledge in one sentence: we know more than we can tell. Every job involves knowledge that is not in the manual: how an exception is resolved, whom to call, which figure never adds up.
A new system can change exactly those parts. And that knowledge is hard to pass on in a presentation. Much of it is rebuilt in practice.
What to do with this
- Design training around real cases from the work itself.
- Plan the environment: time to practise, support from the supervisor, a go-to person nearby.
- Provide support on the job after training, not only before launch.
- Check whether the initiative asks for something the environment cannot sustain today.
More in Training matters, but it is not enough and in Geyto Learning.
Geyto Research publishes essays, evidence reviews and market notes on what happens after go-live.
Frequently asked questions
What is training transfer?
It is the degree to which what is learned in training is applied on the job and maintained over time. Baldwin and Ford studied it through three groups of factors: the learner, the training design and the work environment.
Why don't people apply what they learned?
Because the environment does not allow it or does not ask for it: there is no time to practise, the supervisor does not back it, the previous routine is still available or the real situation differs from the one that was taught.
What is situated learning?
It is the idea, developed by Lave and Wenger, that people learn by taking part in a real practice alongside others, not only by receiving information outside it.
Sources
- Baldwin, T. T. and Ford, J. K. (1988). Transfer of training: A review and directions for future research. Personnel Psychology, 41(1), 63–105.
- Lave, J. and Wenger, E. (1991). Situated Learning: Legitimate Peripheral Participation. Cambridge University Press.
- Polanyi, M. (1966). The Tacit Dimension. University of Chicago Press.
Share